Proposed Resolution No. 311
AdoptedResolution Requesting the Supreme Court of the Philippines to Facilitate the Immediate Organization of the Shari’áh High Court in the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM)
Filed
Referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System
DEFERRED
Committee Report No. 55 RE: PR No. 311 Adopted
Adopted as Resolution No. 458 as amended subject to styleNow
Voted on and adopted by Parliament.
What this measure does
Parliament would request the Supreme Court to immediately facilitate the full organization of the Shari'ah High Court in the region. Copies would go to the Office of the Chief Justice, the Office of the Clerk of Court and the Office of the Court Administrator, and to Chief Minister Ahod Balawag Ebrahim for favorable endorsement to the Court.
Filed on 19 June 2023 by MP Don Mustapha A. Loong and 11 other principal authors, with 40 co-authors. It was referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System on 18 July 2023 and deferred on 20 May 2024. Parliament adopted Committee Report No. 55 on it on 22 May 2024 and, the same day, adopted it as amended as Resolution No. 458.
Why it was proposed
Article X of the Organic Law creates a Shari'ah High Court within the region as part of the Philippine judicial system: 5 Justices including a Presiding Justice, with the rank and pay of Court of Appeals Justices, hearing appeals from Shari'ah courts inside and outside the region, its decisions final except on questions of law. The Supreme Court appoints Shari'ah court personnel, and until the High Court is organized, Shari'ah court decisions go to the Court of Appeals. Section 7, Title V, Book III of the Bangsamoro Administrative Code (BAA No. 13) lets Parliament recommend that the Court completely organize the High Court in Cotabato City. A Shari'ah appellate court was first provided for in Republic Act No. 6734, the first ARMM Organic Act. The authors say organizing it would put appeals before experts in Shari'ah and Muslim personal law.
Who it affects
- Litigants in Shari'ah courts inside and outside the region, whose appeals now go to the Court of Appeals.
Who would implement it
- Supreme Court of the Philippines, asked to organize the court
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Adopted as amended on 22 May 2024 as Resolution No. 458, after Committee Report No. 55.
- A request to the Supreme Court, which Parliament cannot direct; it binds no one.
In committee
Committee Report No. 55, Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System, 15 December 2023: recommended adoption without amendment.
- The committee took up the resolution at its 4th meeting on 16 October 2023, with members unanimous on the need to organize the Shari'ah High Court in BARMM.
- On Deputy Speaker Nabil Tan's motion, the 13 committee members present were made authors, and the resolution was approved unanimously on MP Randolph Parcasio's motion.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the floor debate on this measure; what the committee found is above. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only.
What to notice
The filing cites the Organic Law as 'Republic Act No. 11504' instead of 11054, an error that carried into the adopted Resolution No. 458. The adopted text also sends a copy to the Philippine Congress-Bangsamoro Parliament Forum. The filing names only MP Loong as introducer; Parliament's index lists 12 principal authors.
Sources