Proposed Resolution No. 494
AdoptedResolution Requesting His Excellency President Ferdinand “Bongbong” R. Marcos, Jr Through the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) to Appoint Judges in Vacant Shari’a District Courts (SDCs) Established Under Presidential Decree 1083, Otherwise Known as the “Code of Muslim Personal Laws of the Philippines”
Filed
Referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System
Committee Report No. 115 RE: PR No. 494 Adopted
Adopted as Resolution No. 516Now
Voted on and adopted by Parliament.
What this measure does
The proposal would have Parliament request President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr., through the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC), to appoint judges to the vacant Shari'a District Courts created under Presidential Decree No. 1083, the Code of Muslim Personal Laws. Copies would go to the Office of the President and the JBC.
Filed on 12 January 2024 by MP Baintan A. Ampatuan, with 23 co-authors. It was referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System on 16 January 2024, which reported on it in Committee Report No. 115, and it was adopted as Resolution No. 516 on 23 January 2025.
Why it was proposed
Under the Constitution, lower-court judges are appointed by the President from at least 3 nominees the JBC lists for each vacancy. Presidential Decree No. 1083 created 5 Shari'a judicial districts, each with 1 district court: Sulu; Tawi-Tawi; Basilan and the Zamboanga provinces and cities; the Lanao provinces with Iligan and Marawi; and Maguindanao, North Cotabato and Sultan Kudarat with Cotabato City. JBC records as of June 2021 showed only the 4th and 5th courts had a presiding judge, and it was the same judge, acting in the 5th. The Supreme Court website, the proposal says, now shows the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 5th posts vacant. It argues that the shortage clogs dockets, that justice delayed by the lack of a judge is no redress at all, and that parties without hope of a ruling may turn to extra-judicial means.
Who it affects
- Litigants in Shari'a District Courts, mainly Muslim Filipinos in the 5 Shari'a districts
Who would implement it
- Office of the President
- Judicial and Bar Council
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Adopted as Resolution No. 516 on 23 January 2025, about 1 year after filing.
- A request to the President and the JBC; it binds neither and sets no deadline.
In committee
Committee Report No. 115, Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System, 17 September 2024: recommended adoption without amendment.
- The committee approved the resolution with no amendments on 27 August 2024.
- The author, MP Baintan Ampatuan, said the resolution came from a winning entry by Abdullah Mandungay in her office's youth Bill Drafting Contest.
- The committee cited the Supreme Court website showing the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 5th Shari'a District Court judgeships vacant, and warned the shortage could cause case backlogs and push parties to settle claims outside the courts.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the floor debate on this measure; what the committee found is above. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only.
What to notice
A footnote says the proposal was inspired by an entry by Abdullah E. Mandugay in a 2023 bill and resolution drafting contest run by the offices of 4 MPs; that entry addressed the request to the Supreme Court rather than the President. Resolution No. 516 keeps the request but standardizes the spelling to 'Shari'ah'. Parliament had earlier asked Congress for more Shari'a courts in Resolution No. 177 (14 October 2021).
Sources