Proposed Resolution No. 297
AdoptedResolution Respectfully Requesting the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) to Exempt Applicants for Judgeship Positions in the Shari’ah Courts Within the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) from the Philja’s Pre-Judicature Program Requirement
Filed
Referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System
DEFERRED
Committee Report No. 54 RE: PR No. 297 adopted
Adopted as Resolution No. 457 as amendedNow
Voted on and adopted by Parliament.
What this measure does
Parliament would request the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) to exempt applicants for judgeships in the Shari'ah courts within the region from the Philippine Judicial Academy's (PHILJA) Pre-Judicature Program requirement. A copy would go to the JBC.
Filed on 15 June 2023 by MP Sha Elijah B. Dumama-Alba, with 52 co-authors. It was referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System on 22 June 2023 and deferred on 20 May 2024. Parliament adopted Committee Report No. 54 on it on 22 May 2024 and, the same day, adopted it as amended as Resolution No. 457.
Why it was proposed
The Supreme Court supervises all courts (Article VIII, Section 6 of the Constitution), including Shari'ah courts in the region (Article X, Section 2 of the Organic Law; Article 137 of Presidential Decree No. 1083), and the JBC recommends appointees to the judiciary. The JBC opened applications for judgeships in Regions IX to XII on 19 May 2023. Under Section 2, Rule 3 of the 2020 Revised JBC Rules, all applicants must have completed PHILJA's Pre-Judicature Program, except those applying to Shari'ah Circuit Courts outside the region. The resolution says Shari'ah courts apply the Code of Muslim Personal Laws and special procedural rules, while the program mostly covers regular Philippine law, and that an exemption would encourage qualified candidates.
Who it affects
- Applicants for Shari'ah court judgeships in the region.
Who would implement it
- Judicial and Bar Council, asked to grant the exemption.
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Adopted as amended on 22 May 2024 as Resolution No. 457, after Committee Report No. 54.
- A request to a national body Parliament cannot direct; it binds no one.
In committee
Committee Report No. 54, Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System, 15 December 2023: recommended adoption with amendments.
- Members argued the PHILJA pre-judicature program covers only regular Philippine law subjects, which may not suit Shari'ah courts with their limited jurisdiction under PD 1083.
- Instead of asking the Judicial and Bar Council to exempt Shari'ah judge applicants, the committee changed the resolution to ask PHILJA to offer a separate pre-judicature program for them.
- The title, the 9th whereas clause and the resolving clause were rewritten to match.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the floor debate on this measure; what the committee found is above. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only.
What to notice
The committee changed the request: the adopted Resolution No. 457 no longer seeks an exemption but asks PHILJA to offer a separate Pre-Judicature Program for Shari'ah court applicants, though the copy still goes only to the JBC. It took 11 months from filing. Its companion filed the same day, PR No. 298 on extending the JBC deadline for Muslim applicants, was adopted within a week as Resolution No. 352.
Sources