Proposed Resolution No. 104
In committeeA Resolution Urging All Educational Institutions Within Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao to Exempt Practicing Muslim Students from Joining Tasks with Prohibited Acts in Islam in Their Physical Education Classes and Assign Different Tasks Instead
Filed
Enhanced
Referred to the Committee on Basic, Higher and Technical Education
Committee Report No. 90 RE: PR No. 104 Adopted
Referred back to the committeeNow
Referred to a committee for study. It moves further only if that committee reports it back, and this is the stage where public input carries the most weight.
What this measure does
Parliament would urge all schools, colleges and universities in the region to exempt practicing Muslim students from physical education tasks that Islam prohibits, such as singing, dancing and certain exercises, and to assign them different tasks instead. Copies would go to the Ministry of Basic, Higher and Technical Education, the schools divisions and every educational institution in the region, and a copy would be posted in a conspicuous place, such as the bulletin board, of every school.
Filed on 23 November 2022 by MP Abdullah B. Hashim, with 39 co-authors, and enhanced on 25 November 2022. It was referred to the Committee on Basic, Higher and Technical Education on 17 January 2023. Committee Report No. 90 on it was adopted on 15 October 2024, but the measure was referred back to the committee the same day, where it remains.
Why it was proposed
The filing cites the Constitution's guarantee of free exercise of religion and the Organic Law's call for respect of the distinct beliefs and customs of the Bangsamoro people. It says physical education classes at every level include singing, dancing and music, and that Muslim students, especially women who wear the face veil (niqab), have trouble complying, which hurts their grades. It grounds the request in the Islamic code of modesty (haya) and quotes Qur'an verses Al-Ahzab 32, Luqman 6 and An-Nur 31, with commentary attributed to Ibn 'Abbas, Hasan Al-Basri, Ibn Mas'ud and Ibn 'Umar, on singing, music and women's adornment.
Who it affects
- Practicing Muslim students in the region's schools, colleges and universities, especially women who wear the niqab.
- Physical education teachers.
Who would implement it
- Ministry of Basic, Higher and Technical Education
- Schools divisions
- Educational institutions in the region
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Back in the Committee on Basic, Higher and Technical Education since 15 October 2024.
- An urging resolution; it would bind no school, and changes no curriculum by itself.
In committee
Committee Report No. 90, Committee on Basic, Higher, and Technical Education, 19 August 2024: recommended adoption with amendments.
- The committee, meeting on 23 July 2024, deleted the word 'practicing' from the title and resolving clause so the exemption covers all Muslim students, not only practicing ones.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the floor debate on this measure; what the committee found is above. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only.
On the floor
- 17 January 2023Journal No. 14
Referred to the Committee on Basic, Higher and Technical Education.
What to notice
It is the only proposal in the index on physical education. It got further than most in committee: a committee report was adopted nearly 2 years after referral, yet the measure was sent back to committee the same day and has not returned to the floor. The printed copy lists 15 co-authors; the index lists 39.
Sources