Parliament Bill No. 13
First readingAn Act Creating the Ministry of Tourism, Appropriating Funds Therefor, and for Other Purposes
Filed
First ReadingNow
Filed and formally read into the record, then referred to committee. No debate has happened yet.
What this measure does
This creates a Ministry of Tourism as the region's primary government agency for tourism, with powers and functions, a structural organization, a Minister and Deputy Minister appointed by the Chief Minister, ministry services, and Tourism Provincial Field Units it is authorised to establish.
Section 10 does the transfer: the existing Bureau of Tourism and its officers and personnel are absorbed into the new ministry.
The pattern is the one MP Mawallil used across his reorganisation bills — lift an existing bureau out of the ministry that houses it, give it ministry rank, and move the staff with it.
Why it was proposed
Tourism in the region currently sits as a bureau inside the Ministry of Trade, Investments and Tourism, which is to say it competes for attention with trade and investment promotion. The argument for a ministry is that a region with Lake Lanao, the Sulu and Tawi-Tawi seas, a distinct material culture and a long coastline has a tourism proposition that a bureau cannot develop.
The counter-argument the bill does not address is security. Tourism depends on travel advisories, and the region's are not favourable — which is a constraint no change of organisational rank affects.
Who it affects
- Staff of the existing Bureau of Tourism, whose office is absorbed into the new ministry.
- The Ministry of Trade, Investments and Tourism, which loses a third of its name and mandate.
- Provinces, which would gain Tourism Provincial Field Units.
- Tourism operators and communities with heritage or natural sites.
Who would implement it
- Ministry of Tourism, headed by a Minister and Deputy Minister appointed by the Chief Minister
- Tourism Provincial Field Units, which the Ministry is authorised to establish
Funding
Carries an appropriation. No amount is named; the title carries "appropriating funds therefor" and the figure is left to the appropriations act. As with the author's other reorganisation bills, the starting point is the budget of the bureau being absorbed.
What changes if it becomes law
- Tourism gains ministry rank and a budget line of its own.
- The Bureau of Tourism is abolished and its staff transferred.
- Provincial tourism field units become possible.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the debate on this measure. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only, and no committee report on it has been published.
On the floor
- 27 September 2022Journal No. 5
Read on first reading; the journal records no committee referral at this stage. Private member bill (former minority bloc: MPs Mawallil, Alamia, Ambolodto, Mitmug, Jr. and others).
What to notice
This belongs to a pattern worth seeing whole. The same member filed bills creating a Ministry of Agrarian Reform and a Ministry of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources and renaming MAFAR the Ministry of Agriculture; another member filed bills splitting the education ministry into 4 agencies and the environment ministry into 2. Add this one and the First Regular Session received proposals to turn 4 existing ministries into 10.
None of them passed, and the reason is probably arithmetic rather than principle. Each new ministry needs a Minister, a Deputy Minister, ministry services and field units, and the region's own Administrative Code fixes the cabinet it has. A Parliament that approved all of these would have roughly doubled its executive overhead in a single term.
Where this bill is weaker than its siblings is in the case for separation. Agrarian reform has an adjudicative function that sits oddly beside agricultural extension; fisheries serves island provinces that mainland-led ministries tend to overlook. Tourism and trade, by contrast, are complementary — both are about attracting outside money — and the bill does not explain what the bureau cannot do that a ministry could.
Like most of the measures still at First Reading, this one has never been referred to a committee. The registry shows what that means in practice: of the bills filed in the Second Parliament, the ones that became law were overwhelmingly referred within months, while a measure left at First Reading can sit for years — MP Alamia's transitional justice bill waited 2 years and 9 months there before moving, and then passed in 3.
Sources