Proposed Resolution No. 31
In committeeResolution Requesting the Supreme Court of the Philippines for the Ten (10) Years Moratorium on the Application of the Qualifications of the Shari’ah Judges as Stipulated in the Bangsamoro Organic Law
Filed
Referred to Committee on Bangsamoro Justice SystemNow
Referred to a committee for study. It moves further only if that committee reports it back, and this is the stage where public input carries the most weight.
What this measure does
The proposal requests the Supreme Court to grant a 10-year moratorium on applying the Organic Law's qualifications for Shari'ah judges. It is to be submitted to the Office of the Chief Justice.
Filed on 20 September 2022 by MP Baileng S. Mantawil, with 21 co-authors. Referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System on 27 September 2022, where it has stood for 4 years as of October 2026.
Why it was proposed
Section 8, Article X of the Organic Law requires a Shari'ah Circuit Court judge to be a Muslim, a regular member of the Philippine Bar, at least 30 years old, with 5 years of law practice and at least 2 years of Shari'ah or Islamic jurisprudence; a Shari'ah District Court judge must be at least 35 with 10 years of practice. The proposal says few Bangsamoro professionals can meet these, and those who can are not interested 'for unknown reason'; citing 'our recent survey', it warns that without a moratorium the Shari'ah courts created under Presidential Decree No. 1083 will 'die a natural death'. It would return to the Decree's standards: for district judges, the ordinary qualifications plus learning in Islamic jurisprudence; for circuit judges, a natural-born citizen at least 25 years old who has passed the Supreme Court's Shari'ah Bar examination. It points to the Organic Law's own clause letting the Court give incumbent judges who are not regular Bar members a reasonable period to qualify.
Who it affects
- Shari'ah court judges and applicants for Shari'ah judgeships
- People whose cases go to Shari'ah courts
Who would implement it
- Supreme Court of the Philippines
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Still in committee. Even if adopted, it is a request; the qualifications are set by Republic Act No. 11054 and the resolution cannot change them.
Raised during deliberations
No published record of the debate on this measure. Parliament’s journals cover sittings up to March 2023 only, and no committee report on it has been published.
On the floor
- 27 September 2022Journal No. 5
Referred to the Committee on Bangsamoro Justice System.
What to notice
It asks the Court to suspend for 10 years qualifications written into a statute, while the provision it cites in support only allows incumbents a 'reasonable period' to qualify. The survey it relies on is not named and gives no figures. Parliament later took a narrower route on the judge shortage: Resolution No. 457 (22 May 2024) asked the Philippine Judicial Academy for a separate pre-judicature program for Shari'ah applicants.
Sources