Parliament Resolution No. 94
AdoptedResolution Respectfully Requesting the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) to Exercise Utmost Caution and Prudence in Issuing Statements, Especially on the Institution of the Madaris, Which Might Further Alienate the Muslims in the Philippines to Deleterious Perceptions
Voted on and adopted by Parliament. Resolutions express its position; unlike an act, most are not binding on outside bodies.
What this measure does
Parliament respectfully requests the Armed Forces of the Philippines to exercise utmost caution and prudence in its statements, especially about madaris (Islamic schools), which might further alienate Muslims in the Philippines. A copy goes to the AFP Chief of Staff for his information and guidance.
Authored by MP Paisalin P. Tago and MP Ustadz Abdulmuhmin A. Mujahid. Adopted on 17 November 2020.
Why it was proposed
On 13 October 2020, AFP Chief of Staff General Gilbert Gapay said madaris were institutions of radicalisation. The authors call the statement untrue and sweeping, warning that it breeds distrust among Muslim youth, especially after the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2020. They note that the madrasah curriculum was integrated into the national system under DepEd Order No. 51, s. 2004, that the Organic Law makes the Bangsamoro Government responsible for madaris, and that Ulama summits in Cotabato City and Zamboanga City in 2017 denounced terrorism. They say any proof of madaris recruiting terrorists should be shown in the proper venue before public statements are made.
Who it affects
- Madrasah students and teachers, estimated in the text at 100,000 to 150,000 students in 1,000 to 2,000 madaris in Mindanao.
- The Armed Forces of the Philippines.
Who would implement it
- Armed Forces of the Philippines
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- It is a request to a national body; it sets no consequence and asks for no reply.
Raised during deliberations
- 17 November 2020: MP Paisalin P. Tago urged passage even though AFP Chief of Staff Gilbert Gapay had retracted his statement on madaris, as a reference for future officials.
- 17 November 2020: MP Bai Maleiha B. Candao attributed the issue to a communication gap and urged dialogue between the AFP chief and Islamic leaders; MP Hamid Aminoddin D. Barra suggested asking the AFP to study Islam as a religion of peace.
- 17 November 2020: MP Omar Yasser C. Sema proposed toning down the language since the MILF and MNLF are now partners of the Government; the Chair agreed.
- 17 November 2020: Consolidated Proposed Resolutions No. 328 and 330 approved unanimously.
On the floor
- 17 November 2020Journal No. 44
Read, treated as a simple resolution and transferred to the Business for the Day.
- 17 November 2020Journal No. 44
MP Paisalin P. Tago spoke for Proposed Resolutions No. 328 and 330, which were then consolidated; MP Abdulmuhmin A. Mujahid also spoke (Appendix B).
- 17 November 2020Journal No. 44
MP Omar Yasser C. Sema's proposal to tone down the language was accepted, with the rewriting left to the Majority Floor Leader and Secretariat.
- 17 November 2020Journal No. 44
Consolidated Proposed Resolutions No. 328 and 330 approved unanimously.
What to notice
The resolution came 35 days after the statement it answers. It does not ask the AFP to retract, only to be careful and to bring any proof to a proper proceeding. The figures on madaris are estimates the text gives without a source.
Sources