Parliament Resolution No. 36
AdoptedUrgent Resolution Requesting the Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) Through Ministry of Interior and Local Government (MILG) to Clarify Its Memorandum Circular Number 2019-121. Re: Directing All Provincial Governors, Mayors, Punong Barangays and BARMM Regional Governor to Clear Roads by Illegal Structures and Constructions
Voted on and adopted by Parliament. Resolutions express its position; unlike an act, most are not binding on outside bodies.
What this measure does
Parliament asks the Department of the Interior and Local Government, through the regional Ministry of the Interior and Local Government, to clarify Memorandum Circular No. 2019-121 on clearing roads of illegal structures. It poses 4 questions: what area the circular covers; how it treats titled lot owners; whether the clearing amounts to road widening, entitling owners to just compensation; and whether local executives, rather than the Department of Public Works and Highways, may demolish structures within 15 meters of the centre of a national highway.
Copies go to the DILG Secretary, the DPWH Secretary and the BARMM Minister of the Interior and Local Government. Authored by MP Sittie Shahara I. Mastura. Adopted on 20 September 2019.
Why it was proposed
After President Duterte's 2019 State of the Nation Address, the DILG issued the circular on 29 July 2019 giving local executives 60 days to show results, requiring weekly reports and warning of administrative cases for non-compliance. Some local executives treated 15 meters from the centre of national highways as right of way and removed everything in it. Titled owners argue that this is taking property without just compensation, that the circular does not mention a 15 meter measurement, and that clearing national highways is the DPWH's job.
Who it affects
- Titled lot owners along national highways whose structures were removed or threatened.
- Local chief executives facing administrative cases if they did not comply and lawsuits if they did.
Who would implement it
- Department of the Interior and Local Government
- Ministry of the Interior and Local Government
- Department of Public Works and Highways
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- It asks a national department for an interpretation; it cannot stop any clearing operation.
- Copies go to the DILG, the DPWH and the regional interior ministry.
Raised during deliberations
- 19 September 2019: MP Sittie Shahara I. Mastura said some local chief executives were widening roads, treating 15 meters from the highway center as right of way, which requires compensation.
- 19 September 2019: The Majority Floor Leader cited DILG Secretary Año that Memorandum Circular 2019-121 covers only road obstructions and not road widening.
- 19 September 2019: MP Baintan A. Ampatuan asked whether the circular was officially received by the BARMM or only circulated on Facebook, saying the BARMM is not bound otherwise.
- 19 September 2019: MP Suharto M. Ambolodto asked that a Committee on Local Government look into acts already done in good faith by local officials.
- 19 September 2019: Adopted subject to style on motion of MP Laisa Alamia; the adopted index lists it as Resolution No. 36.
On the floor
- 19–20 September 2019Journal No. 17
Treated as a simple resolution and included in the Business for the Day.
- 19–20 September 2019Journal No. 17
MP Sittie Shahara I. Mastura gave sponsorship remarks.
- 19–20 September 2019Journal No. 17
Adopted subject to style on motion of MP Laisa Alamia; the adopted index lists it as Resolution No. 36.
What to notice
The resolution sets out the lot owners' arguments in detail but takes no position of its own beyond asking for clarification, and names no town, case or count of structures removed. It also asks for nothing to be paused while the answer is awaited, even though the circular's 60 day reporting window was running.
Sources