Parliament Resolution No. 33
AdoptedResolution Expressing Support for the Filing of House Bills No. 3543, 3418 and 3922 Seeking to Compensate the Marawi Siege Victims, and Earnestly Praying for Their Consolidation and Swift Passage
Voted on and adopted by Parliament. Resolutions express its position; unlike an act, most are not binding on outside bodies.
What this measure does
Parliament expresses support for House Bills No. 3543, 3418 and 3922, which seek a law giving monetary compensation for the losses suffered by the people of Marawi. It prays that Congress consolidate the bills and enact them swiftly, and sends the resolution to the Speaker of the House of Representatives for appropriate action.
Authored by MPs Eddie M. Alih, Hamid Aminoddin D. Barra, Paisalin P. Tago, Ziaur-Rahman A. Adiong and Anna Tarhata S. Basman. Adopted on 30 August 2019.
Why it was proposed
The Organic Law lists reparations, including just compensation and relocation, as part of transitional justice. The resolution recounts the toll of the Marawi Siege of May to October 2017: more than 1,000 dead, 98% of the city's population displaced, 95% of structures in the 4 square kilometre main battle area heavily damaged or collapsed, 3,152 buildings completely destroyed and 2,145 more partly to heavily damaged. Where compensation cannot come from the offender, it says, the state should provide it.
Who it affects
- Residents of Marawi who lost family, homes or property in the 2017 siege.
Who would implement it
- House of Representatives
Funding
No appropriation. The resolution appropriates nothing.
What changes if it becomes law
- Nothing changes unless Congress acts; the resolution is an expression of support.
- A copy goes to the Speaker of the House of Representatives.
Raised during deliberations
- 30 August 2019: MP Ziaur-Rahman Alonto Adiong proposed adding House Bill Nos. 3428 and 3922 to the sixth Whereas clause; the author accepted, but MP Adiong later withdrew it and moved to drop the clause naming bill authors.
- 30 August 2019: MP Paisalin Tago objected that commending congressmen for filing a bill is inappropriate since it is their duty, and warned of setting a precedent.
- 30 August 2019: MP Eddie Alih defended recognizing congressmen whose bills help Marawi siege victims and moved for division of the house if the objection stood.
- 30 August 2019: MP Hamid Aminoddin Barra proposed rewording the title to 'expressing support to the filing' so the body would not be commending the filer.
- 30 August 2019: MP Alzad Sattar said members should first ask what the people have felt from the BTA's work in 6 months, saying his inbox is full of complaints.
- 30 August 2019: Speaker Ali Pangalian Balindong moved approval subject to style without naming the House bill authors; MP Paisalin Tago subscribed and the motion carried.
- 30 August 2019: Approved subject to style on motion of Speaker Ali Pangalian Balindong, without naming the House bill authors; the adopted index lists it as Resolution No. 33, retitled as expressing support for House Bills 3543, 3418 and 3922.
On the floor
- 30 August 2019Journal No. 15
Approved subject to style on motion of Speaker Ali Pangalian Balindong, without naming the House bill authors; the adopted index lists it as Resolution No. 33, retitled as expressing support for House Bills 3543, 3418 and 3922.
What to notice
Parliament pressed this issue repeatedly. Resolution 14 (26 June 2019) had already backed a compensation law for Butig, Piagapo and Marawi. Resolutions 151 and 156 (September 2021) asked the Senate to move its bill; Resolution 216 (17 February 2022) appealed to President Duterte to sign Senate Bill No. 2420 and House Bill No. 9925, the Marawi Siege Victims Compensation Act; and Resolution 308 (24 January 2023) thanked President Marcos for constituting the Marawi Compensation Board. The 3 House bills named here were not the numbers that reached the President.
Sources