Parliament Bill No. 54
ApprovedCabinet measureAn Act Appropriating Funds for Operation of the Bangsamoro Government from January One to December Thirty-One, Two Thousand and Twenty-Three and for Other Purposes
Filed
First Reading
Second Reading (Authorship Speech)
Referred to Committee on Finance, Budget and Management
Approved on Third and Final Reading
BAA No. 32Now
Passed third reading. This measure has cleared Parliament.
What this measure does
This is the region's proposed budget for 2023 — the FY 2023 Bangsamoro Expenditure Program, ₱85,359,315,687.00, filed as a cabinet bill and enacted as BAA 32 with the total unchanged.
Section 1 names where the money comes from: the annual block grant, other subsidies from the National Government, the region's share of national taxes, fees and charges collected inside its territory, unutilized prior years' appropriations sitting in the Bangsamoro Treasury, and projected collections on the region's own taxes, fees and charges.
The volume runs to some 270 pages and funds 17 ministries, 11 other executive offices and 5 special purpose funds — Personnel Gratuity, Miscellaneous Personnel Benefits, Contingent, Special Development, and the Local Government Support Fund — followed by a staffing summary and 24 pages of general provisions.
3 of those general provisions do more than housekeeping, and all 3 are in the bill as filed rather than added later. Section 18 requires every ministry and office to buy common-use supplies through the Procurement Service, with local governments free to do the same. Section 21 caps engineering and administrative overhead at 1% of project funds, and only for infrastructure costing more than ₱1,000,000. And Section 50 provides that funds transferred between organizational units within a ministry, between ministries, or from a ministry out to a local government are not considered disbursed until the transferred amounts have actually been used to pay for completed construction, goods delivered and services rendered, inspected and accepted within the validity period.
Section 50 also sets the year's clock: appropriations available until 31 December 2023, infrastructure completion and payment to 30 June 2024, delivery and payment of operating and other capital items to 31 March 2024, with unreleased appropriations lapsing and unexpended funds reverting to the Treasury under a Special Fund for reappropriation.
Why it was proposed
An annual appropriations bill needs no explanatory note and this one has none. Its argument is its arithmetic.
What the bill does argue, in its general provisions, is about control rather than allocation. Routing common-use supplies through a central procurement service, capping project overhead at 1%, and refusing to count a transfer as a disbursement are 3 answers to the same question: whether the money the budget reports as spent has actually bought anything. That question is the one the region's own extension bills — 127, 128, 179, 265 and 266 — keep raising without answering.
Who it affects
- Every ministry, office and special purpose fund of the Bangsamoro Government, whose year's money this is.
- Constituent local government units, through the ₱2.3 billion Local Government Support Fund and their share of taxes collected in the region.
- Suppliers of common-use goods, who must now sell through the Procurement Service rather than to each ministry.
- Contractors and implementing offices, whose engineering and administrative overhead is capped at 1% of project funds.
- Any agency that reports a fund transfer as spending, which can no longer do so until the money has paid for something delivered and accepted.
Who would implement it
- Ministry of Finance, and Budget and Management — release, guidelines and the cash budgeting system
- Every ministry and office named in the expenditure program, for its own appropriations
- Procurement Service, for common-use supplies
- Bangsamoro Treasury, which receives unexpended funds under a Special Fund for reappropriation
Funding
Carries an appropriation. ₱85,359,315,687.00 for fiscal year 2023 — the same total the enacted act carries. Sources are the annual block grant, other National Government subsidies, the region's share of national taxes, fees and charges collected in its territory, unutilized prior years' appropriations from the Bangsamoro Treasury, and projected collections on regional taxes, fees and charges.
What changes if it becomes law
- The region's 2023 operations are funded at ₱85.36 billion across 17 ministries, 11 other offices and 5 special purpose funds.
- Common-use supplies must be bought through the Procurement Service.
- Engineering and administrative overhead on infrastructure above ₱1 million is capped at 1% of project funds.
- A fund transfer stops counting as a disbursement until the money has paid for something delivered and accepted.
- Unexpended appropriations revert to the Treasury for reappropriation at the end of the validity period.
In committee
Committee Report No. 2, Committee on Finance, Budget, and Management, 20 December 2022: recommended approval with amendments.
- The committee kept the 2023 budget total at P85.36 billion after subcommittee hearings on each ministry, agency and office.
- It cut the Contingent Fund by P2.03 billion, from P6.84 billion to P4.81 billion, and moved the money to ministries and offices, whose total rose to P70.12 billion.
- The largest increases went to the BTA Parliament (P785.39 million), MILG (P780.40 million), MOH (P194.03 million) and MSSD (P180.34 million); the Office of the Chief Minister was cut by P25.66 million and MOTC by P6.03 million.
Raised during deliberations
- 20 December 2022: MP Jose I. Lorena asked whether ₱85,000,000,000 was the whole fiscal space; sponsor MP Ubaida C. Pacasem said it covers the block grant, tax shares, local taxes and 2020 and 2021 savings, but not projected 2022 savings.
- 20 December 2022: MP Jose I. Lorena worried that extending older appropriations prolongs projects and asked about the organic law’s preference for local residents; MP Ubaida C. Pacasem pointed to procurement-law provisions in the budget since 2020.
- 20 December 2022: MP Baintan A. Ampatuan argued Section 58 lets ministries modify allotments the Parliament approved; MP Ubaida C. Pacasem replied the rule was taken from the national budget and only shifts activities within a program.
- 20 December 2022: MP Baintan A. Ampatuan noted ministries’ accomplishment stood at 30% from January to October and sought a mid-year review by the finance committee; MP Ubaida C. Pacasem said oversight needs no special provision and cited election, plebiscite and reappointment bans.
- 20 December 2022: MP Benjamin T. Loong asked to insert ₱100,000,000 for tractors from the ₱2,000,000,000 Special Purpose Fund or ₱6,000,000,000 Contingent Fund; MP Ubaida C. Pacasem declined, saying those funds are earmarked.
- 20 December 2022: MP Baintan A. Ampatuan called the MOOE-to-Capital Outlay modification a technical malversation and moved to delete it and add semi-annual review; on division of the house it lost, 17 in favor, 22 against, 3 abstentions.
- 20 December 2022: Nominal vote: 45 in favor, 0 against, 0 abstentions. Nominal voting on third and final reading, 20 December 2022; 45 in favor, none against, no abstention.
- 20 December 2022: Nominal vote: 17 in favor, 22 against, 3 abstentions. Division of the house by show of hands on MP Baintan A. Ampatuan’s proposed amendment during the period of amendments; not approved. No names recorded.
- 20 December 2022: Certified urgent by the Chief Minister, approved on third and final reading the same day by nominal voting, 45 in favor, 0 against, 0 abstentions.
What to notice
The total did not move. ₱85,359,315,687.00 is what the Government of the Day proposed and ₱85,359,315,687.00 is what BAA 32 appropriates, to the peso. A legislature reviewing an executive budget and returning the identical figure is a fact about this Parliament worth recording plainly, and it is visible only by reading the filed bill against the act.
The 3 provisions that make this budget notable are also the cabinet's, not Parliament's. Section 50's transfer rule — the one that stops a ministry counting money as spent the moment it moves it somewhere else — is in the bill as filed, as are the Procurement Service requirement and the 1% overhead cap. It is the finance ministry tightening the rules on itself and its colleagues, which is not the direction these things usually run. The same transfer rule reappears a year later in Bill No. 266, extending it into the 2023 budget's afterlife, so whoever drafted it kept at it.
There is one conflict inside the document that a reader should know about. General provision Section 21 caps engineering and administrative overhead at 1% of project funds for all ministries and offices. The special provisions for the Ministry of Public Works authorise it to deduct a maximum of 3%, and up to 2% for releases to District Engineering Offices, for the same purpose on the same class of projects. 2 ceilings, 1 document, and nothing on the face of the bill that says which governs the ministry that builds most of the region's infrastructure.
Read alongside the extension bills, the budget's control provisions look less like routine drafting and less like optimism. A government that in the same period was repeatedly legislating to keep unspent appropriations alive was also writing rules to make sure the spending it did report was real. Both things are responses to the same underlying problem, and only 1 of them is usually discussed.
Sources