Parliament Bill No. 29
ApprovedCabinet measureAn Act Providing for the Bangsamoro Electoral Code of the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao
Filed
First Reading
Deferred
Second Reading (Authorship Speech)
Referred to Committee on Rules
Committee Report Adopted
Approved on Third and Final ReadingNow
Passed third reading. This measure has cleared Parliament.
What this measure does
This is the region's first election law, filed as a cabinet bill on the opening filing day of the Second Parliament and enacted as BAA 35 just under 6 months later. 14 articles across 62 pages, covering the electoral office, the tribunal, political parties, every elective position, the electorate, the administration of the vote, and the offenses.
The Parliament it describes has 80 members: 50% party representatives elected region-wide by proportional representation, 40% district representatives, and 10% reserved and sectoral seats — never fewer than 8. 2 of those are reserved for non-Moro indigenous peoples and 2 for settler communities, with 1 each for women, youth, traditional leaders and the 'Ulama. Party seats go only to parties clearing 4% of the valid votes cast, each of which files a ranked list of up to 40 nominees before the vote.
Article V is the part that does the most work, and it is not about voting at all. It regulates the internal life of political parties. A party needs 10,000 residents with voting rights to be established, distributed as far as practicable across the provinces and cities, with chapters in every province and city and in a majority of the municipalities of each province. It must have a constitution and by-laws covering 11 enumerated subjects, and it must have 6 organs: an Executive Committee of at least 5 elected every 3 years, a General Party Committee of at least 20 elected by proportional geographic representation, a Delegates Committee that nominates the party's candidates, Local Branches, a Membership Committee, and a Party Arbitral Committee whose members must hold a Juris Doctor and at least 1 of whom must be a full member of the Philippine Bar. Every one of these is elected by secret ballot. No one may belong to 2 regional parties — doing so forfeits membership in both — and where a member's regional party conflicts with a national party they also belong to, they must uphold the regional one or forfeit their regional membership.
The government's own tenure is in here too. The Chief Minister must already be a member of Parliament, serves 3 years, and may not serve more than 3 consecutive terms. 2 Deputy Chief Ministers must come from the 2 subregions the Chief Minister does not — the Code names 3: South Western Mindanao, North Central Mindanao and South Central Mindanao. And a vote of no confidence by 2/3 of all members obliges the Chief Minister, within 72 hours, to advise the Wali to dissolve Parliament and call an election within 120 days. The Wali may not countermand that advice. A government may face such a vote only once in a term, and not within a year of taking office or within a year before a regular election.
Why it was proposed
Section 2 states the purpose in the vocabulary of institutional design rather than reform: to prescribe the structural, functional and procedural principles for elections in the region, and to secure honest, credible, just and free elections allowing democratic political participation and reflecting the genuine will of the electorate.
The real answer is in the Organic Law, which required the region to legislate its own electoral code and left it without one. Section 4 adds the interpretive instruction that follows from that: where the Code is ambiguous, the parliamentary ministerial nature of the Bangsamoro Government is always to be taken into account. A region switching from an executive-and-council system to a parliamentary one cannot borrow a national election law wholesale, and this Code is the answer to that problem more than to any particular electoral grievance.
Who it affects
- Every voter in the region, whose Parliament, districts and ballot this Code defines.
- Political parties, which must restructure their internal governance — organs, committees, secret-ballot elections, arbitral procedures — to be registrable at all.
- Anyone holding membership in both a regional and a national party, who must choose the regional one in a conflict or lose it.
- Non-Moro indigenous peoples — Teduray, Lambangian, Dulangan Manobo, B'laan and Higaonon are named — whose 2 reserved seats are to be filled through their own customary laws and consensus processes.
- Settler communities, women, youth, traditional leaders and the 'Ulama, each with reserved or sectoral seats.
- The Commission on Elections, which retains control and supervision over the Bangsamoro Electoral Office and carries its budget.
- The Chief Minister and the government of the day, whose tenure, succession and vulnerability to a no-confidence vote are set here.
Who would implement it
- Bangsamoro Electoral Office — a Chief Electoral Officer and 2 electoral officers, with 6 bureaus: Party Representation, Constituency Representation, Election Assessors, Provincial Operations, National and Local Elections, and Administration and Finance
- Commission on Elections, which establishes the BEO, keeps it under its control and supervision, and carries its budget
- Bangsamoro Parliament Electoral Tribunal — sole judge of contests relating to the election, returns and qualifications of members, with rules patterned on those of the House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal
- Ministry of Indigenous Peoples' Affairs, Bangsamoro Women Commission, Bangsamoro Youth Commission and the Regional Darul Ifta', each certifying the sectoral parties in its field
- The Wali, who dissolves Parliament on the Chief Minister's advice after a successful no-confidence vote
Funding
No appropriation. No appropriation. The Bangsamoro Electoral Office is funded within the yearly budget of the Commission on Elections, without prejudice to a supplemental budget from Parliament to augment its operational expenses. The Code separately authorises the BEO to collect legal fees.
What changes if it becomes law
- The region acquires an election law of its own, where it had been running on national law written for a different form of government.
- Parliament's composition is fixed at 80 seats, split 50% party, 40% district and 10% reserved and sectoral, with a floor of 8 reserved seats.
- A 4% threshold decides which parties get seats at all.
- Political parties become regulated institutions with mandatory internal organs, elected by secret ballot, and an arbitral committee staffed by lawyers.
- Dual membership in 2 regional parties forfeits both, and regional loyalty outranks national party loyalty on pain of forfeiture.
- A no-confidence vote by 2/3 of members forces dissolution within 72 hours and an election within 120 days, with the Wali unable to refuse.
- Non-Moro indigenous representation is to be settled by customary law and consensus rather than by campaign.
In committee
Committee Report No. 5, Committee on Rules, 7 March 2023: recommended approval with amendments.
- The committee held 12 public consultations in 9 places, from Quezon City in October 2022 to Basilan, Sulu, Tawi-Tawi, Cotabato City, Midsayap, Buluan, Datu Odin Sinsuat and Marawi City through January 2023, and processed 106 position papers.
- A small group led by chair Sha Elijah Dumama-Alba with Raissa Jajurie, Mary Ann Arnado, Anna Tarhata Basman and Jose Lorena conferred with the Commission on Elections on the Code's wording.
- Amendments added a declaration of principles favouring principled regional political parties over personality-based politics and promoting gender inclusivity, and new definitions including turncoatism, reserved seats, sectoral representation seats and non-Moro indigenous peoples.
- The committee resolved on 6 March 2023 to recommend approval after 10 days of meetings over 1 month.
Raised during deliberations
- 26 September 2022: MP Babao asked whether Bill No. 29 had been referred; the Chair said referral comes on second reading after the authorship speech, and MP Parcasio was told its first reading was on 22 September 2022.
- 27 September 2022: MP Mastura noted there is no Committee on Electoral Reform and Suffrage, and that no bills had been filed creating municipalities in the 63 SGA barangays, which he said must come before districts can be drawn in the Electoral Code.
- 17 February 2023: MP Ambolodto asked whether Members would get COMELEC's comments on the Electoral Code; MP Dumama-Alba said they had not been officially transmitted, but as Rules Committee chair she would obtain and circulate an official copy.
- 17 February 2023: MP Hadji Abdullah asked why the schedule gave more days to the Committee on Rules than to plenary; MP Dumama-Alba said it was indicative and faster committee work would leave more days for plenary debate.
- 7 March 2023: MPs Ampatuan and Mawallil pressed for the basis of the 10,000-member requirement for regional parties; MP Dumama-Alba said it reflects over 2,000,000 registered voters and guards against fly-by-night parties, and is neither required nor barred by the BOL.
- 7 March 2023: MP Lorena said the 10,000-member rule would shut out smaller groups and favour rebel fronts and existing parties, and would have set the threshold at 2.5% to 3% at first with a higher bar for coalitions, but said he had been outvoted in the Committee on Rules.
- 7 March 2023: MP Ampatuan noted 30% of 40 party seats is 12, fewer than the 16 women then sitting, and with no zipper rule no women may be seated; MP Alih replied the 30% is a floor, above the 24.1% global average.
- 7 March 2023: MP Mastura argued that votes for parties outside the party-list system breach Article IX-C, Section 7 of the Constitution; MP Dumama-Alba said party-list is one form of proportional representation and the Party-List Law applies only nationally.
- 7 March 2023: MP Ambolodto questioned the Parliament's power to impose 6 months to 6 years' imprisonment for election offenses; MP Dumama-Alba said the penalty comes from the Omnibus Election Code and the BOL's general welfare clause allows it.
- 7 March 2023: MP Tago defended the 10,000-member rule as small against a population of 4,000,000 and said fewer members would multiply parties as in the national party-list, which he said exceeded 300.
- 7 March 2023: Nominal vote: 64 in favor, 0 against, 0 abstentions. Nominal voting on third and final reading on the night of 8 March 2023: "With sixty-four (64) votes in favor, none against, and none abstention, the BTA-Parliament Bill No. 29 was passed on Third and Final Reading."
- 7 March 2023: As a certified urgent bill, approved on third and final reading by nominal voting, 64 in favor, 0 against, 0 abstentions; Members then explained their votes.
On the floor
- 17 February 2023Journal No. 20
MP Dumama-Alba presented a revised schedule: small-group relanguaging 20 to 25 February, Committee on Rules amendments 27 February to 2 March, committee report and plenary deliberations 6 to 8 March, and enactment on 9 March 2023.
What to notice
The footnotes are the first thing to notice, because filed bills in this registry do not have any. This one cites the Electoral Code of Macedonia for its definition of a coalition, Malaysia's Elections Act 1958 for its definition of an elector, and the rules of the House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal for the tribunal's procedure — and it marks its own departures, noting where a provision is "proposed additional" and why. The drafters left their working out on the page. For a region writing its first election law under a form of government it had never used, showing which comparative source each borrowed mechanism came from is a form of accountability, and it did not survive into the enacted statute, where footnotes have no place.
Article V is where the Code makes its real argument. Almost none of it is about elections; it is about what a political party has to be internally before it may contest one. 10,000 founding members, chapters in every province and city, 6 mandatory organs elected by secret ballot every 3 years, and an arbitral committee that must include a member of the Bar. In a region where politics has run on families and personal followings, requiring a party to have a written constitution, a membership committee and an internal court is an attempt to build something that outlives the person who founded it. Whether a statute can manufacture that is the open question, and the Code's own interpretive rule — resolve ambiguity toward the parliamentary and party-based reading — shows the drafters knew it would be tested.
2 tensions in the filed copy are worth recording, because they were resolved somewhere in committee and the resolution is not published. Sectoral representatives are nominated by Parliament through the Speaker and appointed by the Chief Minister under Section 22 — but Section 26 says the non-Moro indigenous seats are determined by plurality of votes, and states it twice, once as "the Parliamentary Election conducted for the purpose" and once as "the elections to be conducted by the Parliament for that purpose". An election among voters and an election among members of Parliament are entirely different things, and the filed bill contains both sentences. Separately, the age ceiling for a youth candidate is 25 in Section 8 and 30 in Section 21.
The no-confidence provisions are the most consequential thing here and the least discussed. Two thirds of all members can end a government, and once the vote succeeds the Chief Minister has 72 hours and no discretion: the advice to dissolve must be given, and Section 28(4) says the Wali shall in no case countermand it. That is a deliberate closing of the one door through which a ceremonial head of region might have become a political actor. Against it sits the limit of 1 no-confidence vote per term, which protects a government from being harried — and means that a government which survives its single challenge cannot be removed by Parliament again before the next election.
The Code has already been amended twice, both on the same day in January 2026: BAA 87 removed the "none of the above" option from the ballot, and BAA 88 amended BAA 35 directly.
Sources